Cari Blog Ini

Juni 12, 2012

ASSIGNMENT 7, topics in applied linguistics >> sex, politeness, stereotypes

Men dominate the talking time. In conversations involving members of both sexes, men speak more than women do. When men talked to men, the content categories of such talk focused on competition and teasing, sport, aggression and doing things. In the other hand, when women talked to women, the equivalent categories were the self, feelings, affiliation with others, home and family. When ...
the two sexes interacted, men tended to take the initiative in conversation, but there seem to be a desire to achieve some kind of accommodation so far as topics were concerned: the men spoke less of aggression and competition and the women reduced their amount of talk about home and family. Men tend to explain things to women and in doing so to patronize them, whereas women tend to apologize to men.

There are many features of interaction which differentiate the talk of women and men: interruption behavior and conversational feedback.
1.      Interruptions
In the same sex-interactions, interruptions were pretty evenly distributed between speakers. In cross-sex interactions almost all the interruptions were from male. It has been found that men interrupt others more than women do. Men interrupt more, challenge, dispute, and ignore more, try to control what topics are discussed, and are inclined to make categorical statements. Women are evidently socialized from early childhood to expect to be interrupted. Consequently, they generally give up the floor with little or no protest.

2.      Feedback
Another aspect of the picture of women as cooperative conversationalists is the evidence that women provide more encouraging feedback to their conversational partner than men do. In cross-sex conversation, women ask more question than men, encourage others to speak, use more signal like mhmm to encourage other to continue speaking, use more instant of you and we, and do not protest as much as men when they are interrupted. The mhmm a woman uses quite frequently means only “I’m listening”, whereas the mhmm a man uses, but much less frequently, tends to mean “I’m agreeing”.

The distinction between men’s and women’s language is a symptom of a problem in our culture, and not primarily the problem itself. Rather, it reflects the fact that men and women are expected to have different interests and different roles, hold different types of conversations and react differently to other people.
Men and women differ in the kinds of language they use and how they use it because men and women often fill distinctly different roles in the society. The more distinct the role, the greater the differences, and there seems to be some evidence to support such a claim, for the greatest differences appear to exist in societies in which are the roles of men and women are most clearly differentiated.